My final theory about the sugar bowl

[Optimism is my Phil-osophy]

This is part 9 of the Strange Interpretation of Jean Lúcio from Brazil

To understand this thread, it is necessary to read my previous threads.


1 - asoue.proboards.com/thread/35828/lemony-snickets-narration-culturally-different
2 - asoue.proboards.com/thread/35834/lemony-dialogues-events

3 - asoue.proboards.com/thread/35835/little-chronology-theory

4 - asoue.proboards.com/thread/35843/daniel-handler-duplicates-events-confuse

5 - asoue.proboards.com/thread/35845/great-hiatus-theory-enigma

6 - asoue.proboards.com/thread/35847/letter-lemony-sent-real

7 - asoue.proboards.com/thread/35850/beatrice-alive-years-after-house

8 - asoue.proboards.com/thread/35854/explanation-secret-letter-tss


I would like to tell my story with the sugar bowl. It was one of the first things that fascinated me in ASOUE. When I was a child, I wanted to find the answer that suited me anyway. But as much as I spent hours reading and thinking, I could not find satisfactory answers.
I could only stop thinking about the sugar bowl when I read Beatrice Letters. That's when I began to think about What Happened to Beatrice. And it was on this subject that my mind kept working for a long time. But then, during a certain rainy afternoon, I was rereading ATWQ. I began to think about The Great Unknown. And so, I decided to publish last year my conclusions about Beatrice on a Portuguese wordpress blog called www.beatriceestaviva.wordpress.com and soon after on a YouTube channel called "Beatrice está viva" in Portuguese. I did not spend much time trying to figure out what the Great Unknown really was. My focus was on Beatrice. But suddenly, I watched a video of a Brazilian youtuber called Nifrido. He has also loved ASOUE since childhood. He has a twin brother named Evezel, and when they were younger, they made videos about ASOUE, and I watched them with a lot of interest. Well, last year, Nifrido posted a video proving with all possible evidence, including material evidence, that the Great Unknown is Bombinating Beast.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4NBKYHXSTw
 I already thought that, but his video was so enlightening, that suddenly a flash came in my mind. The real reason for the mystery behind the sugar bowl is that to solve this mystery you first need to solve several others. But when you come across the answer, you say to yourself, "That's certainly it," because that answers everything. You say to yourself, "I finally untied the Gordian knot."
Perhaps it would have been better to have explained my interpretation of TBL before explaining this theory of the sugar bowl. But maybe not. The sugar bowl theory is supported by answering the following wrong questions: (I'll give the short answer, and then I'll have to explain each of the answers in a future text).

1 - Who really is JS? - The JS who was the recipient of the secret code found in the refrigerator is Beatrice. At the time she was pretending to be Jacques Snicket after the death of Jacques Snicket.
2 - Is Beatrice a short woman? "Yes. She even gets to be a 10-year-old with ease. Maybe she can get through a mailbox or a dog. And that's why she can walk in GG.
3 - What is the Great Unknown - It is Bombinating Beast that has grown.
4 - Is the Great Unknown capable of being controlled? - Yes, by means of sounds.
5 - Is the Great Unknown able to carry people in his mouth? "Yes, because he was trained for it."
6 - What was in the sugar bowl hat belonged to Esmé? "There was a musical instrument capable of controlling the Great Unknown." Probably a kind of whistle.
7 - Why did one of the Quaquimires shout the name Violet when he was about to be swallowed by the Great Unknown? "Because he saw a woman in the Beast's mouth." The woman was similar to Violet and had a short stature. He said "Violet ?!"
8 - Why did Windershins choose to go to the Great Unknown if he knew that the Great Unknown was a dangerous animal? And why did he show fear of the Great Unknown while he was in the Queequeg with the Baudelaires, but showed no fear when the Queequeg was hit by Hector's house? "Because he knew Beatrice had taken the sugar bowl into the Gorgonian Grotto, and so Windershins knew Beatrice was controlling the Beast. He knew that the Beast came here to rescue them, not to kill them.
9 - Why did Kit, who knew what it was and even saw the Great Unknown, wondered if the Beast killed Windershins and the others, or if he rescued them? "Because Kit did not know if the sugar bowl had fallen into the hands of noble people or cruel people. Besides, the beast could be acting on its own, not through control of the whistle.
10 - When did Beatrice get the sugar bowl? "Beatrice first came to the Gorgonian Grotto. She must have been informed by Windershins with the help of a telegram on where the sugar bowl was, after Klaus calculated where he was. Similarly, Windershins must have been warned by Beatrice that the sugar bowl had been thrown out the window of the secret base, and that it would land in the ocean. She managed to do this, because she managed to reach the secret base of VFD and received the message hidden in the refrigerator. As Madame Lulu said, if one of the Baudelaire's parents were alive, he or she would be at the base of VFD. The problem is that Beatrice arrived after her children in the base of operations.
11 - "Who was the woman who persuaded Windershins to abandon the Queequeg?" "It was Beatrice, already in possession of the sugar bowl. She came down from AA through a secret tunnel.

12. Where did Windershins and Bill go when Beatrice arrived with the sugar bowl? "Windershins, Bill and Beatrice left Queequeg in their wetsuits and went to the Beast's mouth. Using the Great Unknown with fast transport, Windershins, Beatrice and Bill reached the shore faster than the Queequeg and the Carmelite.
13 - Why did JS send a telegram to Mr. Poe asking Mr. Poe to meet Klaus, Sunny and Violet at Briny Beach? "Because this JS was Beatrice pretending to be Jacques Snicket. Beatrice does not want her children to get even more involved with VFD.

Each of these answers needs to be detailed so that the theory becomes believable. I should do this in a future text.

[Foxy]

The idea of Beatrice being the mysterious woman in the grotto is highly intriguing! But what about at the end of TGG when the Great Unknown is swimming near the Carmelita and the Queequeg?

[Optimism is my Phil-osophy]

Mar 17, 2019 13:17:26 GMT -5 Foxy said:

The idea of Beatrice being the mysterious woman in the grotto is highly intriguing!

Thank you!

Mar 17, 2019 13:17:26 GMT -5 Foxy said:

But what about at the end of TGG when the Great Unknown is swimming near the Carmelita and the Queequeg?

This is the part you should be referring to. Chapter 13 TGG:

The screen looked like a piece of graph paper, lit up in green light, and at the center were both a glowing letter Q, representing the Queequeg , and a glowing eye, representing the terrible octopus submarine that had devoured them. But at the top of the screen was another shape – one they had almost forgotten about. It was a long curved tube, with a small circle at the end of it, slithering slowly down the screen like a snake, or an enormous question mark, or some terrible evil the children could not even imagine.
"What's that cakesniffing shape?" asked Carmelita Spats. "It looks like a big comma."
"Shh!" Count Olaf hissed, putting his filthy hand over Carmelita's mouth. "Silence, everyone!"
"We have to get out of here," Esmé murmured. "This octopus is no match for that thing."
"You're right," Olaf muttered. "Esmé, go whip our rowers so they'll go faster! Hooky, store those uniforms! Triangle Eyes, take the orphans to the brig!"
"What about me?" Carmelita asked. "I'm the cutest, so I should get to do something."
"I guess you'd better come with me," the count said wearily. "But no tap-dancing! We don't want to show up on their sonar!"
"Ta ta, cakesniffers!" Carmelita said, waving her pink wand at the three siblings.
"You're so stylish, darling," Esmé said. "It's like I always say: You can't be too rich or too in !"
The two wicked females jumped through the broken porthole and out of the Queequeg , followed by the hook-handed man, who gave the Baudelaires an awkward wave.



According to my theory, TGU was around at this point because Beatrice, Bill and Windershins had invoked TGU using the musical instrument (probably a whistle).
Olaf refers to the sonar that would be used by "them." This sonar should be a bio sonar, used by some animals for echolocation.  Olaf uses the plural "their," because Olaf knows there is more than one animal that has the same shape. Although only one of them, I think, is trained by Lemony and his associates (Or Hangfire many years before).


It is interesting that Olaf and Esmé know that TGU has the ability to listen to low amplitude sounds. Some marine animals like dolphins and whales have bio sonar. Such animals need a good ear. In addition, the name given to the animal was Bombinating Beast. This means that the animal makes a sound while hunting. This sound can be used for echolocation. Olaf and Esmé know that TGU will prefer to attack the Carmelita. According to Nifrido, this is because the Carmelita has a shape of octopus. Octopuses would be the food of the TGU, and so the octopuses were disappearing from the city Stain'd-by-the-Sea. TGU was eating the octopus.

[Dante]

That's not at all why the octopi were vanishing from the region of Stain'd-by-the-Sea, and there'd been no sightings or evidence of anything like the Bombinating Beast around town for so many years that it had receded into myth until Hangfire discovered how to raise another one. But in isolation, "Bombinating Beasts eat octopi" is a reasonable premise.